The annual meeting of the National Association of
Research in Science Teaching conference was held in New Orleans
from April 7-10 2002. NARST publishes the Journal of Research in
Science Teaching, which is the primary academic journal for publications
covering the topics of science teaching and learning.
Several hundred
talks on student learning of science were presented at the conference.
Two major topics were of interest to me as Director of Biology Laboratories
at Barnard College: (1) Current curriculum changes at the K-12 level
and (2) Research on student learning of evolution.
Current curriculum
changes at the K-12 level are of central importance to Barnard College
because we must be aware of what students have learned about
science and how they were taught science before they attend
our biology courses. Barnard’s current biology curriculum does not
include any components of the Nature of Science (NOS), which is
a major new focus of science education at all levels of the K-12
curriculum in the United States. NOS is a recommended component
of K-12 and the college curriculum by the National Academy of Sciences,
the National Research Council, and Project 2061. The Barnard biology
faculty should be aware of NOS research and incorporate it in their
curricula. In addition to research on NOS, there is a trend towards
what is known as “authentic science.” This paradigm was incorporated
into the new BC2003 curriculum (Fall, 2001) and it clear from the
conference that this approach should be expanded into the other
lab courses.
Several talks
focused on student learning of evolution. It is now quite clear
that students who obtain high grades in evolution courses often
remain committed creationists and often lack a sophisticated understanding
of evolution. This is a product of several factors relating to course
content. Based on talks at the conference, the most important content
factor is Alternative Conceptions (ACs) of the nature of science
(NOS). In addition to content factors, it is clear that lecturing
on evolution has been demonstrated to be ineffective at facilitating
student understanding of evolution. Problem solving laboratories
have been demonstrated to promote student understanding of evolution
more effectively.
In summary,
information presented at the conference suggests new directions
in which the Barnard Biology curriculum can grow.