Are sugar substitutes safe?


Sugar substitutes, both no and low calorie, are popping up everywhere and in everything lately. The majority of the low-cal and light foods we eat contain some kind of artificial sweetener. Unless you are eating or drinking really huge amounts of foods that contain sugar substitutes, you probably don't have anything to worry about.

So what about sugar substitutes that you add to things like coffee and tea? The most common artificial sweeteners you can buy or find in a restaurant are Splenda, Equal, and Sweet N Low. Of the three, Splenda is generally considered to be the safest. This is because it has undergone, and passed with flying colors, a variety of safety tests. Equal is considered safe for most, but some people claim that it can cause headaches. This hasn't been conclusively proven. Sweet N Low should be avoided, because there is some evidence that saccharin (the chemical in Sweet N Low) increases risk for bladder cancer when taken in very large amounts: six or more servings of the sweetener or two eight-ounce servings of diet drinks that contain the sweetener.

Its important to remember that any sugar substitute is probably safe in small amounts, say, a few light yogurts or a diet soda here and there. Also keep in mind that regular sugar itself isn't unhealthy or unsafe if eaten in small amounts. Moderation is the key!

Well-Woman Fun Fact: Saccharin (the synthetic chemical in Sweet N Low) was discovered in 1879 when a researcher spilled a compound on his hand, tasted it, and realized it was sweet!

(Info taken from Sweet Nothings: Not All Sweeteners are Equal, by David Schardt, Nutrition Action Health Letter, May 2004)

back to Living Well index